
Teofimo Lopez Must Choose Between His WBA Belt and the Ryan Garcia Payday
Boxer Ryan Garcia after defeating Luke Campbell in 2021.Image: Ryan Garcia / CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons
Teofimo Lopez may still get the Ryan Garcia fight, but the WBA has made one thing clear: he cannot treat Jack Catterall’s mandatory challenge as an inconvenience while continuing to market himself as the organization’s welterweight Super Champion.
On November 11, the WBA Championships Committee upheld its order requiring Lopez to face Catterall, rejecting Lopez’s request for reconsideration. The organization gave the two champions 10 calendar days to reach an agreement or present another proposed resolution. If they fail to do so, either side may request a purse bid.
That ruling disrupts Garcia’s publicly stated route toward the undisputed welterweight championship. Garcia told The Ring in September that he wanted to face Lopez during Cinco de Mayo weekend in 2027, add the WBA title to his WBC championship and then pursue Devin Haney.
Garcia-Lopez has not been officially canceled because no signed fight was confirmed in the reviewed reports. Boxing News described the fighters as being in early discussions, and several possible resolutions remain available.
Under the WBA’s current position, however, the proposed matchup cannot proceed as a WBC-WBA unification unless Lopez resolves the Catterall obligation or persuades the organization to change course.
That leaves Lopez with a career-defining business decision. He can defend the title that gives him leverage against Garcia, negotiate another WBA-approved solution or pursue the more commercially attractive fight without any guarantee that his belt will follow him into it.
The WBA Says Lopez Inherited an Existing Obligation
The Catterall mandatory did not appear after Garcia and Lopez began discussing a major fight.
According to the WBA, the obligation can be traced to May 20, when the organization elevated Rolando Romero to Super Champion and ordered him to face the winner of Catterall’s bout with Shakhram Giyasov within 180 days. The WBA recorded that Catterall defeated Giyasov on May 23 to win its welterweight world championship.
Lopez then defeated Romero by majority decision on August 22. When Lopez took Romero’s position as WBA Super Champion, the organization says he also inherited Romero’s responsibility to face Catterall.
The WBA formally ordered Lopez-Catterall on September 22 and opened a 30-day negotiating period. That window expired on October 22 without an agreement. Lopez’s team had submitted a request for reconsideration on October 2, according to the organization, but the Championships Committee ultimately upheld the mandatory.
The WBA’s October 2026 rankings identify Lopez as its Super Champion, Catterall as its world champion and Garcia as the WBC champion in the 147-pound welterweight division. That title structure may be unnecessarily complicated, but the organization’s present demand is not: Lopez is expected to deal with Catterall before using the WBA championship in another fight.
The new 10-day period gives both sides another opportunity to negotiate. It does not guarantee they will actually fight, and the WBA has left room for an alternative proposal. But if there is no agreement or acceptable resolution, a purse bid can be requested.
Lopez therefore faces more than a recommendation. He faces an active championship obligation with a deadline and an enforcement mechanism.
Lopez’s Reported Permission Filing Remains Disputed
The most important factual disagreement concerns whether Lopez’s team properly requested special permission to pursue the Garcia unification.
In announcing its November 11 decision, the WBA said Lopez’s team had not submitted the formal special-permission request required under Rule C.39. From the organization’s perspective, the committee was reviewing a request to reconsider the Catterall order—not a completed application seeking authorization for a unification.
Chris Mannix reported a different account on November 12. According to Mannix, Lopez’s team says it filed a unification-permission request on November 5 and plans to appeal again.
That claim is relevant, but it remains unconfirmed and disputed because it conflicts directly with the WBA’s statement about what was before the committee when it ruled. The available reporting does not establish whether a November 5 submission existed, whether it satisfied the organization’s formal requirements or whether the WBA will consider it through another process.
The distinction matters. If Lopez’s team can demonstrate that it filed a valid request under the correct rule, the argument may move from whether permission was sought to whether the WBA should grant it. If the filing was incomplete, misdirected or never formally received, Lopez remains bound by the ruling already issued.
Another appeal could extend the dispute, but announcing an intention to appeal does not suspend the mandatory by itself. Unless the WBA says otherwise, Lopez and Catterall remain inside the 10-day resolution period established on November 11.
Documentation should settle this part of the story. Until then, the responsible conclusion is that Lopez’s team says it requested unification permission while the WBA says no formal request of that kind was before it.
Neither account should be converted into an established fact without further evidence.
The Ruling Changes the Stakes, Not Necessarily the Fight
The WBA decision has already been described as a rejection of the Garcia-Lopez unification, but that language requires precision.
The organization has not declared that Garcia and Lopez can never fight. It has reaffirmed that Lopez must address Catterall before proceeding with the WBA title attached under the present circumstances.
Several outcomes are still possible.
Lopez could reach an agreement to defend against Catterall and preserve his championship status. The parties could propose another arrangement acceptable to the WBA. Lopez could obtain special permission if the organization determines that the Garcia fight warrants an exception. He could also relinquish or lose recognition as champion and pursue Garcia without the WBA belt.
Each option changes the meaning of Garcia-Lopez.
With Lopez recognized as WBA Super Champion and Garcia holding the WBC title, the fight advances Garcia’s stated undisputed plan. It becomes a two-belt unification between prominent fighters whose rivalry carries significance beyond their names.
Without Lopez’s WBA championship, it may remain a major event, but it no longer moves Garcia one title closer to undisputed status. Garcia would be facing Lopez for the matchup itself rather than for the specific divisional progress he outlined to The Ring.
That difference also affects Lopez. His name, accomplishments and drawing power do not disappear without the belt, but the WBA title strengthens his position in negotiations. It allows him to offer Garcia something Garcia has publicly said he wants.
The championship is part of the commercial package.
That is why abandoning the Catterall obligation is not as simple as choosing a bigger fight over a smaller one. Lopez would risk removing the feature that turns the Garcia bout from a high-profile attraction into a unification carrying direct consequences for the welterweight championship picture.
Lopez Must Decide What Kind of Leverage Matters Most
A Garcia fight appears to offer Lopez the larger stage, but no purse has been established in the supplied reporting and no signed contract has been confirmed. The commercial assumption may be reasonable given both fighters’ profiles, yet an anticipated opportunity is not the same as a completed deal.
Catterall offers something less glamorous but more immediate: a defined path to preserving Lopez’s WBA position.
Defeating Catterall would satisfy the mandatory, protect the championship and remove the strongest regulatory obstacle to a later Garcia unification. It would also carry competitive risk. Catterall has already earned the WBA’s recognition by defeating Giyasov, and Lopez would have to place the very belt he wants to bring into the Garcia negotiations on the line.
That is the tension.
Fighting Catterall protects Lopez’s championship legitimacy but risks losing the title in the ring. Avoiding Catterall may accelerate negotiations with Garcia but risks losing the WBA’s recognition outside it. Waiting for another appeal could produce special permission, but it could also consume time without changing the organization’s position.
Lopez’s strongest outcome would be a WBA-approved arrangement allowing him to face Garcia while preserving a clearly defined route for Catterall. Whether the organization or Catterall would accept such a proposal remains unknown.
Catterall also has little reason to surrender his position without receiving something meaningful. The WBA recognizes him as its world champion, and he has waited through the original negotiating period while Lopez pursued reconsideration. From his perspective, the mandatory is not administrative interference in somebody else’s major event. It is the title opportunity the organization says he earned.
Garcia, meanwhile, must decide whether Lopez remains the right next opponent if the WBA belt is removed. The fight would still carry attention, history and personal intrigue, but it would no longer execute the plan Garcia publicly described.
The next documents and decisions will matter more than another round of public positioning. A confirmed agreement between Lopez and Catterall, a purse-bid request, a valid special-permission ruling or Lopez’s decision regarding the belt would establish where the situation is actually headed.
Until one of those things happens, Garcia-Lopez remains possible—but not as the unification currently being sold.
LET’S TALK ABOUT IT
Should Teofimo Lopez defend against Jack Catterall to preserve his WBA leverage, or should he prioritize the potentially bigger Ryan Garcia fight even if it costs him the belt?
If Garcia-Lopez happens without the WBA championship involved, does it remain the right next fight for both men—or should Garcia pursue a unification that keeps his undisputed plan intact?
Outlets cited in this story
- Boxing News
- The Ring
Spot an error? Send a correction.
More on Teofimo Lopez
All 8 Teofimo Lopez stories →
Ryan Garcia Will Reveal His Next Opponent Monday — But Floyd Mayweather and Teofimo Lopez Lead to Different Futures
Ryan Garcia says he will announce his next opponent on Monday, November 23, ending a stretch of speculation that has placed Floyd Mayweather and Teofimo Lopez at the center of…

Ryan Garcia Seeks $100 Million for Floyd Mayweather Fight — But His Real Career Test Remains Unanswered
Ryan Garcia says Floyd Mayweather will be his next opponent, and he has publicly offered the retired champion $100 million to enter a sanctioned professional fight. Garcia has also predicted…

Ryan Garcia’s Mayweather Path Runs Through Bangkok — But Teofimo Lopez Offers Greater Stakes
Floyd Mayweather has publicly placed another exhibition between himself and a proposed fight with Ryan Garcia. According to World Boxing News and Boxing News, Mayweather announced through his verified Instagram…

Ryan Garcia Gives Floyd Mayweather a February 6 Ultimatum — But His Welterweight Reign Remains on Hold
Ryan Garcia has given Floyd Mayweather a deadline, but he has not announced a fight. The WBC welterweight champion says he intends to return on February 6, 2027, and claims…
