Boxing news · REAL TALKNOV 21, 2026
The Boxing Streets
TBS NEWS
Floyd Mayweather Jr. in the boxing ring against Juan Manuel Márquez
REAL TALK · ANALYSIS

Devin Haney Says Floyd Mayweather Can Beat Ryan Garcia — But a WBC Title Shot Raises a Bigger Question

Elijah Stone8 min read3 sources cited

Floyd Mayweather Jr. in the boxing ring against Juan Manuel Márquez.Image: ian mcwilliams / CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Devin Haney believes Floyd Mayweather could defeat Ryan Garcia. He is considerably less convinced that the proposed fight will ever happen.

“I think he can win, but will it happen? I don’t think it will,” Haney told Inside the Ring, according to Boxing News.

That assessment captures the uncertainty surrounding one of boxing’s most ambitious proposed events. Garcia has claimed that he and Mayweather verbally agreed to meet at 147 pounds in a professional fight for Garcia’s WBC welterweight championship. However, no signed contract, confirmed venue, promoter or broadcaster has been announced.

The matchup remains unconfirmed.

Mayweather has also stopped short of publicly matching the certainty of Garcia’s announcement. He has discussed Garcia as a possible opponent, but he later included him among four potential names for a major fight in 2027.

That leaves two separate questions. Could Mayweather still defeat Garcia? Haney believes he could. Should Mayweather be allowed to move directly into a current world-title fight if the event becomes real? That requires a much more difficult answer.

Haney Believes Mayweather Can Win, but His Opinion Is Not Proof

Haney’s assessment carries particular interest because of his history with Garcia. Garcia initially defeated Haney by majority decision on April 20, 2024, but that result was later changed to a no-contest after Garcia tested positive for ostarine.

The New York State Athletic Commission suspended Garcia for one year under a settlement, according to ESPN reporting carried by ABC News.

That history gives Haney an informed perspective on Garcia as an opponent, although it does not make his prediction conclusive. Haney can evaluate Garcia’s speed, timing and tendencies from direct experience, but a proposed fight involving Mayweather presents questions that cannot be answered through reputation alone.

Haney’s comment also avoids the easiest assumption about the matchup. He is not dismissing Mayweather because of his age or the time that has passed since his years as an active championship fighter. He believes Mayweather could win.

That matters because the strongest argument against a Mayweather title shot should not depend on claiming he has no chance.

Mayweather’s technical intelligence, defensive instincts and ability to control the rhythm of a fight built his legacy. It is reasonable that another elite fighter might believe those qualities could still create serious problems for Garcia. A veteran legend being capable of winning, however, does not automatically mean he has earned the right to challenge for a current world championship.

Those are different standards.

One concerns competitive possibility. The other concerns sporting merit.

Haney’s larger doubt may prove more important than his prediction. Until contracts are signed and the necessary parties confirm the event, Mayweather versus Garcia is a proposal surrounded by public statements—not a confirmed championship fight.

Garcia and Mayweather Have Presented Different Levels of Certainty

Garcia made the stronger claim on October 21, saying that he and Mayweather had verbally agreed to fight at 147 pounds for the WBC welterweight championship. AS USA reported Garcia’s announcement while also noting that Mayweather had not personally confirmed the same details and that no contract had been announced.

A verbal understanding can be part of the process, but it does not settle the questions required to produce a professional title fight.

There is no confirmed venue. No commission has been identified as the licensing authority. No promoter or broadcaster has been announced. The WBC has not formally sanctioned the contest, and there has been no public confirmation that Mayweather has completed the medical examinations or obtained the license that would be required.

Mayweather’s own comments have kept the possibility alive without establishing that Garcia is definitely next.

According to BoxingScene, Mayweather described a planned December 19 exhibition against Matty Floyd as a “tune-up” before a possible fight with Garcia. That language suggested Garcia was being seriously considered, but Mayweather later made the situation less definite.

In subsequent comments to Wynn Records reported by BoxingScene, Mayweather said his opponent for a major 2027 fight “could be” Garcia, Oscar De La Hoya, Manny Pacquiao or Conor McGregor.

That is not the language of a finalized matchup.

Garcia may believe an agreement exists, and Mayweather may be interested in making the fight. Both possibilities can be true without the event being complete. Boxing has repeatedly demonstrated the distance between discussing a fight, reaching a verbal understanding and announcing a signed contest with every necessary approval in place.

Even Mayweather’s planned December 19 exhibition remains part of the uncertainty. If it occurs, it could provide some indication of his preparation and current physical condition. It would not prove that the Garcia fight is signed, and an exhibition would not establish his position within the active welterweight division.

The public statements have created attention. They have not yet produced a confirmed title fight.

The WBC Has Left the Door Open Without Approving the Fight

WBC president Mauricio Sulaiman has said that a Mayweather challenge could be considered if Mayweather passes the required medical examinations and obtains a boxing license, according to Boxing News.

That position changes the discussion because it means the governing body has not rejected the possibility of Mayweather challenging for Garcia’s championship.

It does not mean the fight has been sanctioned.

It also does not mean Mayweather has already been medically cleared, licensed or approved as a title challenger. Those remain separate steps, and none should be treated as complete without confirmation from the relevant authorities.

Medical examinations and licensing requirements are essential. A commission must determine whether a fighter is physically eligible to compete, and Mayweather should not receive an exception from those standards because of his name or past achievements.

But passing those examinations would answer only one question: Can he legally and medically participate?

It would not answer why he should immediately compete for a world championship ahead of active welterweight contenders.

That distinction is central to the credibility of the proposed fight. A boxing license establishes permission to box. It does not establish current championship merit. Medical clearance can show that a fighter meets the required health standards, but it cannot serve as a substitute for recent competition, divisional position or an earned route to a title opportunity.

Mayweather’s historic greatness explains why Garcia would want the event and why the WBC would be willing to consider it. His presence would bring attention beyond the division and transform the fight into a major commercial attraction.

Commercial value, however, is not supposed to be the only qualification for a world-title challenger.

If the WBC sanctions the contest, it would be making a statement that Mayweather’s legacy and drawing power are sufficient to place him directly into a championship fight. That decision would affect more than Mayweather and Garcia. It would also tell every active welterweight attempting to earn position that the competitive route can be bypassed when a sufficiently famous opponent becomes available.

Mayweather’s Greatness and His Current Standing Are Separate Issues

Questioning a Mayweather title shot does not require questioning Mayweather’s legacy.

His past accomplishments are the reason the proposal attracts attention. They are also the reason Haney can credibly argue that Mayweather might still possess enough skill to defeat Garcia.

The issue is what Mayweather has demonstrated as a current welterweight contender.

Nothing in the announced details establishes his present position among the division’s active challengers. The reports do not identify a recent qualifying victory, a current ranking or a title-elimination process that would place him at the front of the line. It would therefore be wrong to treat the proposed opportunity as the result of a conventional competitive path.

It would be a special opportunity created by Mayweather’s stature.

Boxing has always balanced sporting merit with commercial reality. Champions pursue the largest available events, promoters search for matchups that can attract broad audiences and sanctioning bodies frequently operate within that marketplace. A Mayweather-Garcia fight would unquestionably generate more attention than many contests involving less famous contenders.

That does not make the championship question irrelevant. It makes it more important.

If Mayweather competed against Garcia in a non-title event, the matchup could be judged primarily as a spectacle between a current champion and a retired legend. Once the WBC belt is involved, the fight carries consequences for the meaning of the championship and the opportunities available to the rest of the division.

A world title is supposed to identify achievement within active competition. If celebrity becomes an independent route to a championship challenge, the belt begins functioning as promotional decoration rather than the reward at the end of a sporting process.

Haney may be completely correct that Mayweather can win. Mayweather could pass every examination, receive a license and enter the ring in excellent condition. None of those possibilities would explain what he did to earn priority over contenders currently competing within the division.

Ability matters.

So does qualification.

The Proposal Still Needs Evidence Before It Becomes a Fight

Several developments would move Mayweather-Garcia from speculation toward confirmation.

Signed contracts would establish that both fighters have formally committed. A confirmed date and venue would identify when and where the event is supposed to happen. An announced promoter and broadcaster would provide the commercial structure necessary to stage it.

The appropriate commission would then need to license Mayweather, and the required medical examinations would need to be completed. If Garcia’s WBC championship is genuinely intended to be at stake, the sanctioning body would also need to formally approve Mayweather as the challenger.

Until those steps occur, no date should be treated as confirmed and no title fight should be presented as official.

Mayweather’s announced December 19 exhibition is another relevant piece of the proposed timeline, but it must first occur as planned. Even then, an exhibition performance would not resolve the question of whether he has earned a championship opportunity.

The cleanest evidence will come through formal announcements from the fighters, the promoter, the broadcaster, the commission and the WBC.

For now, Haney’s skepticism is justified. The fight is possible enough to discuss but incomplete enough to doubt.

LET’S TALK ABOUT IT

If Mayweather passes the required medical examinations and receives a boxing license, should that be enough for the WBC to approve him as a challenger for Garcia’s championship?

Would a Mayweather title shot strengthen the welterweight division through attention, or weaken the championship by placing spectacle ahead of active contenders?

Tell us in the comments

Outlets cited in this story

  1. BoxingScene
  2. Boxing News
  3. ESPN

Spot an error? Send a correction.

Ryan Garcia after defeating Luke Campbell in the boxing ring
REAL TALK · ANALYSIS

Devin Haney Says Emotion Cost Him Against Ryan Garcia — But Liam Paro Will Test the Lesson

Devin Haney has identified the moment when his fight against Ryan Garcia stopped being a tactical contest and became personal. During an interview released by Club Shay Shay on November…

8 min read
Photo: Ryan Garcia / CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia
Boxer Canelo Alvarez during a visit to the official Los Pinos residence in Mexico City
REAL TALK · ANALYSIS

Devin Haney Says Crawford Would Beat Canelo Alvarez “Even Better” — But Would Canelo Have Any New Answers?

Devin Haney believes Terence Crawford would defeat Saul “Canelo” Alvarez more convincingly in a rematch. The prediction arrives at a convenient moment for boxing’s biggest-event machinery: Alvarez has regained a…

7 min read
Photo: Presidencia de la República Mexicana /
Ryan Garcia celebrates in the boxing ring after defeating Luke Campbell
REAL TALK · ANALYSIS

Devin Haney Targets Ryan Garcia After Liam Paro — But the Unification Must Come First

Devin Haney already knows which fight he wants if he defeats Liam Paro on December 19. Speaking to FightHype in comments reported by Boxing News, Haney identified Ryan Garcia as…

8 min read
Photo: Ryan Garcia / CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia
Aerial view of Chase Center and the surrounding waterfront neighborhood in San Francisco
REAL TALK · ANALYSIS

Devin Haney Reportedly Set to Face Liam Paro in San Francisco — But Two Belts Would Only Start the Argument

Devin Haney could begin his new agreement with DAZN by pursuing something more meaningful than a showcase victory. The WBO welterweight champion is reportedly set to face IBF champion Liam…

8 min read
Photo: Christopher Michel / CC BY 2.0 / Wikime

Your corner

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *